Insights & Tips

Already a subscriber? Login

Become a subscriber and unlock an information arsenal focused on making your pricing efforts more effective.

When Average Selling Prices Hide the Truth

It’s probably very clear to regular readers that we’re big proponents of “getting granular” to drive improved pricing performance. Simply put, setting prices that align more precisely to real differences in willingness-to-pay is crucial for winning all the business you want to win, but without leaving any money on the table.

In reviewing a case study for the Journal by Peter Maniscalco, I was reminded of the importance of “getting granular” when measuring pricing performance. In Boosting ASPs (Average Selling Prices) to Drive Profitability, Peter highlights many of the pitfalls of relying on Average Selling Prices as a gauge of pricing performance and pricing process control:

ASPs can be very helpful, but also deceiving. The benefit of using the metric of an average is that it compiles a huge amount of data into a single number for drawing critical conclusions. However, this surface level ‘view’ does not provide insight at the granular level, which can reveal important factors which may be affecting ASPs.

By normalizing the extremes, Average Selling Prices can obfuscate a lot of unprofitable behaviors and outcomes. Consider, for example, how product-specific ASP comparisons between customer segments can effectively hide dramatic differences in the underlying process dynamics:

Segment ASP Comparison Only

At the ASP level, these segments appear to be nearly identical. From this high-level information, it’s tempting to draw the conclusion that Segment A is performing slightly better than Segment B. We might even be tempted to figure out what we need to do differently with Segment B to have it perform more like Segment A.

But when we drill down to a more granular view, we see something very different:

Segment Dispersion ASP Comparison

Now we can see that the outcomes in Segment B are much more consistent and rational than in Segment A. In Segment B, the relationships between price and volume are what we’d expect to see with proper price structures and diligent execution. In Segment A, however, the relatively wide dispersion indicates a lack of process control and haphazard execution.

In all likelihood, any positive ASP differences observed in Segment A are the result of pure luck, rather than intent or design. And emulating what’s happening in Segment A? That would be the last thing we’d want to do.

As Peter makes clear in the case study, averages have their place, certainly. Metrics like Average Selling Price can provide some directional information and even signal major shifts and issues. But if you really want to drive pricing improvements, you’ve got to get below surface-level metrics like Average Selling Price and drill down to a more meaningful…and more revealing…level of granularity.

Get Immediate Access To Everything In The PricingBrew Journal

Related Resources

  • The Fundamentals of Price Segmentation

    In this recorded training seminar, we explain the concept of price segmentation and why it's such a powerful and important tool. We explore the essential process and even walk through a step-by-step exercise, building an example price segmentation model from scratch.

    View This Webinar
  • How to Hire Great Pricing People

    How do you identify pricing candidates with the raw materials to be most successful? In this on-demand webinar, you'll learn the most important attributes you should be looking for when building your team.

    View This Webinar
  • Three Core Pricing Skills That No One Talks About

    For many B2B companies, increasing knowledge around pricing is a priority. But this education regularly ignores skills that are critically important. In this guide, learn about three areas that are often overlooked.

    View This Guide
  • Getting Control of Discounting

    In B2B, discounting tend to be the norm rather than the exception. How do we make sure the discounts are appropriate and warranted? And how do we do it without alienating the sales team?

    View This Webinar